BP Factory in Whiting Indiana
I must admit as soon as I saw this opportunity I jumped for it as it pertains very much to the nature of this blog. First off I will start off with a little explanation of what this is about. BP’s oil refinery in Indiana has just acquired a new permit that allows it to dump more ammonia into Lake Michigan. They are doing this because BP has decided to invest in Canadian Crude Oil instead of the Middle East. Canadian crude oil is thicker and requires a dirtier refining process than conventional crude oil.
Apparently BP, a company known to be environmentally friendly, is upset about an article written by Chigago Tribune. The claims made in the article that BP disagrees with include the fact that their environmental impacts from ammonia are no where near the federal limits which is stated in the article. Furthermore, they deny dumping sludge into Lake Michigan altogether.
According to this a Fact Sheet Released by BP, they have acquired a permit to release more ammonia discharge, however, the amounts being released are less than half of the federal guidelines allow.
The Chicago Tribune article makes the claim that toxic sludge, rich in heavy metals, are being released into Lake Michigan…a pretty serious claim. However, according to BP’s factsheet, there is no sludge being released into Lake Michigan at all. In fact BP claims that they only release treated water which is 99.9% water and not sludge.
BP plans to spend more than $3 billion to modernize the Whiting Refinery to process additional heavy crude oil from Canada, a secure and reliable source. This is a smart move in general and helps to alleviate the need for oil from the Middle East.
One thing I will point out is that on the BP Whiting Refinery Fact Sheet, one of the highlighted facts is that they allow “No harm to people or the environment”, and then proceed to say that they follow federal regulations. I will have to disagree with the first part of the statement…just because a company follows federal regulations does not mean that it does not harm the environment…no matter how much the amount.
While its obvious that BP is trying to protect its image as an environmentally friendly corporation…it seems to me that it is very difficult to determine who is correct as neither BP nor the Chicago Tribune offer any official documentation to backup their claims. The Chicago Tribune says that sludge is being dumped into Lake Michigan yet lacks proof. BP says that its levels of ammonia discharge are within federal limits yet lacks to provide the specific amount it discharges. Nevertheless, the point of this post is for you the readers to take a look at both sides of the story and decide for yourself.



